Free buses sound like the easiest yes in New York politics. Get on, sit down, go. No fumbling for your phone at the OMNY reader, no $3 base fare, no driver telling you the back door is broken so swipe up front. Then the city’s Independent Budget Office did the math, and the math is not friendly. On June 3, 2026, the IBO estimated that making every city bus fare-free could cost as much as $1.1 billion a year, according to amNewYork’s reporting on the analysis. That is roughly $400 million higher than the $700 million Mayor Zohran Mamdani’s campaign had floated.
The fare you pay is not the only thing the city would be eating. The IBO’s $1.1 billion scenario assumes ridership climbs 25 percent once buses are free, and it folds in express buses, the longer-haul coaches that charge a premium $7.25 fare, per amNewYork. More riders riding more often means more service to run, and free express rides mean giving up the priciest tickets on the system. Stack those together and you blow past $1 billion.
The higher cost is partly proof the idea works. When the MTA actually tried it, riders showed up. From September 24, 2023 to August 31, 2024, five routes went fare-free as a pilot: the Bx18A/B in the Bronx, the B60 in Brooklyn, the M116 in Manhattan, the Q4 in Queens, and the S46/96 on Staten Island. Weekday ridership on those lines rose about 30 percent and weekend ridership about 38 percent, and 23 percent of riders said they took the trip specifically because it was free, The Nation reported from the MTA’s own evaluation. The pilot ran the MTA about $12.3 million over nine months. People earning under $28,000 a year drove the biggest jump.







