Skip to content
Bushwick DailyBecome a member
Advertisement
Met FreshMet Fresh

CrimeBoerum Hill

Brooklyn man files federal lawsuit against NYPD over wrongful liquor-store arrest

Timothy Brown's federal complaint, filed Nov. 10, asks a jury to set his damages; the $100 million was his April notice of claim. Civilian Complaint Review Board records list 12 complaints against one detective and eight against the other.

The curved glass entrance of the federal courthouse at 225 Cadman Plaza East in Brooklyn, with United States Courthouse lettered over the doors and a gold eagle above, framed by two trees

Brooklyn man files federal lawsuit against NYPD over wrongful liquor-store arrest

Timothy Brown's federal complaint, filed Nov. 10, asks a jury to set his damages; the $100 million was his April notice of claim. Civilian Complaint Review Board records list 12 complaints against one detective and eight against the other.

Brooklyn man files federal lawsuit against NYPD over wrongful liquor-store arrest
Advertisement
Met FreshMet Fresh

Timothy Brown, whose April arrest by two NYPD narcotics detectives in a Hoyt Street liquor store was caught on video, sued the city, the detectives and three of their supervisors in federal court Nov. 10, saying they beat him after mistaking him for a drug suspect.

Video still from Timothy Brown's federal complaint: inside BK Wine Depot on Hoyt Street on April 14, 2026, two plainclothes NYPD detectives hold a man in a white T-shirt and teal shorts by the head and neck against a glass wall
A still from a customer’s video, reproduced in Brown’s complaint. The complaint says it shows Detective Michael Algerio, at left, gripping Brown’s head and neck while Detective Volkan Maden pins him against the glass wall of BK Wine Depot on April 14. Image: customer video, from the complaint in Brown v. City of New York, U.S. District Court, Eastern District of New York

Detectives Volkan Maden and Michael Algerio “came to that store with records of civilian complaints, substantiated misconduct and lawsuits alleging force, and the City kept them on the street,” the complaint says. The Civilian Complaint Review Board’s public records list 12 complaints against Maden from 2016 through 2021, five of them substantiated against him, and eight against Algerio from 2013 through 2025, one substantiated.

The complaint asks a jury to award compensatory and punitive damages “in an amount to be determined at trial” and names no dollar figure. The $100 million reported as Brown’s demand was the sum in the notice of claim his lawyers at the Cochran Firm served on the city in April, the firm said at the time. His attorney Derek Sells said Nov. 10 that a jury would decide how much Brown should receive, News 12 Brooklyn reported.

Besides the city, the suit names Maden and Algerio, who were assigned to the NYPD’s Brooklyn North Narcotics unit; Lt. Ronald J. Reynolds and Capt. Daniel L. Casella, who it…

Thanks for reading Bushwick Daily.

Create your free account or log in to continue reading.

By continuing, you agree to the Membership Terms and Privacy Policy.

Enjoy unlimited access to all of Bushwick Daily. See membership options

Advertisement
Met Fresh

Thanks for being a member.

Filed underBrooklyn North Narcotics / Civilian Complaint Review Board / Cochran Firm

Bushwick Daily News Desk. Neighborhood news, politics, real estate, and business coverage produced by the Bushwick Daily newsroom.

Produced by Bushwick Daily News Desk

Neighborhood news, politics, real estate, and business coverage produced by the Bushwick Daily newsroom.

View all posts

Read next

News

Federal judge in Brooklyn approves $162 million wage settlement for about 200,000 home care aides

Aides paid through Public Partnerships LLC in New York City, Long Island and Westchester from March 2025 to April 2026 should start receiving payments, averaging about $680, in early 2027 if no one appeals.

‘Jeopardy!’ champion Austin Rogers hosts a free NYC history trivia night at the Municipal Archives December 1

News ·

The Brooklyn Cookie Takedown brings all-you-can-eat holiday cookies from home bakers to Gowanus’ Royal Palms on Dec. 13

Food & Drink ·

Brooklyn rapper Kota the Friend’s FLTBYS teams with TIDAL and brings Flight Night to SOB’s on Dec. 11

Music ·

Advertise with Bushwick Daily

Reach North Brooklyn, and the New Yorkers who read it.

Written in Bushwick, read across the city since 2009.

129K site visitors a month 1–2M Instagram impressions a month 24K email list members
Advertise with us →
Become a member of Bushwick Daily